SPARTA

Agnes6683

12 years ago, the Li Shaobin Pingluo 20 million from Liang Yijun hand to buy a property, then the wife named Ma Liang Yijun Liang Yijun no right to dispose of matrimonial property is by, in 2005, Li Shaobin court. 7 caused a piece of paper the sale of housing lawsuits.
1992 年 9 19, Pingluo county traffic police unit will be located in the North Gate area of 134.29 square meters of the five bungalows, to 2.6 million dollars when sold as deputy leader of the brigade beam A. Wife named Ma Liang Yijun come forward with the traffic police force signed a purchase contract, Liang Yijun pay back the principal. Since then, Liang Yijun housing land use permits will transfer to the named Ma name,[link widoczny dla zalogowanych], but not for property rights transfer procedure.
1998 年 11 1st, Liang Yijun and Li Shaobin signed five contracts for the sale bungalow, agreed Liang Yijun responsible for real estate and land use right transfer procedures. April 5, 1999, Li Shaobin will be paid 200,000 yuan to buy a house Liang Yijun.
As a rule, property rights should be transferred to the named Ma by the traffic police unit under the name of his wife, and then transfer to the couple by the named Ma Li Shaobin name. However, in actual operation, Liang Yijun on January 4,[link widoczny dla zalogowanych], 2000 to come forward, so that Li Shaobin housing contract signings and the traffic police brigade, and he holds the deed to the property management station Pingluo procedures for the transaction, at the same time the notary. Housing tube station issued pursuant to the Li Shaobin January 7 the same year, formal property rights transfer from the traffic police to Li Shaobin name.
2005 by the end of Li Shaobin received a lawsuit filed, the plaintiff is named Ma. Named Ma said her husband represent its November 1, 1998, will house an annual leasing cost of 20,000 yuan to Li Shaobin use, not sell. To this end, the Ping Luo Wenyou traffic police brigade, Li Shaobin court, asked the court to the traffic police brigade and Li Shaobin signed contract for the sale invalid.
court later, in February 8, 2006 verdict: Liang Yijun and Li Shaobin valid signed contract for the sale. The face of the first trial court's decision, named Ma refused to accept the Shizuishan City Intermediate People's Court of Appeal.
waiting for the court process, named Ma Pingluo court to bring an administrative lawsuit, the Pingluo housing management station to court. Wenyou that the review of housing management stand to perform the process of transfer of land ownership did not identify the property, that property transferred to the Li Shaobin agreed, and issued property certificates, appeals court to withdraw
court, Pingluo housing management station that houses the transaction procedure is complete, complete, consistent with the Housing Stock Exchange conditions, and have notarized, in addition, housing management station does not repeat the transaction, not issued in the secondary housing ownership certificate. The court held that the housekeeping Pingluo clear stand did not review the ownership of the property, did not examine whether the traffic police force Pingluo the case with legal personality, that housing ownership certificates issued by the behavior is wrong. In addition,[link widoczny dla zalogowanych], the contract table, there are altered and other issues. June 5,[link widoczny dla zalogowanych],[link widoczny dla zalogowanych], 2006, an administrative court ruling: it removes the
administrative proceedings based on this lawsuit, in November 2006 in September, Shizuishan City Intermediate People's Court verdict: the traffic police brigade and Li Shaobin house sale and purchase agreement entered into is invalid, Mamou Sheng appeal. In this case, Li Shaobin apply to court for retrial, March 2, 2007, Stone City Court dismissed the retrial request.
At this time, this purchase has gone through four lawsuits dispute. In 2007, Li Shaobin in turn named Ma, Liang Yijun court, Pingluo court that Li Shaobin from April 1999 the housing to move into contention, named Ma until the June 2005 lawsuit was filed, from the named Ma, Liang signed with the traffic police force of a housing contract for the sale and delivery Shou Fangkuan of view, the husband and wife, knowing recognized. Therefore, March 24, 2008, Pingluo People's Court verdict: identify and Liang Yijun Li Shaobin signed housing contract for the sale valid.
named Ma satisfied after losing the appeal to the Shizuishan City Court, December 15, 2008, the case has been sent back to Pingluo people's court for retrial. Pingluo court, after a retrial in September 30, 2009 to make civil judgments are still judgments Liang Yijun Li Shaobin signed with the housing contract for the sale valid. Wenyou third suit against an appeal by the Shijiazhuang Intermediate People's Court heard on March 8, 2010 to make civil judgments, and Liang Yijun Li Shaobin judge signed the housing contract for the sale invalid.
By this time, the party has been deceased Liang Yijun, Li Shaobin insisted he had never in the rental agreement. In late June of this year, Li Shaobin again Shizuishan Intermediate People's Court to appeal for re identification of the authenticity of the lease contract, and the return of 20 million to buy a house.